Let me save you the ~$200 I wasted on collars before I figured this out. The flat buckle collar is your everyday workhorse, the martingale is your Houdini insurance, and anything with a prong or a shock button belongs in the trash. That's the whole article in one paragraph. Stick around if you want the details, because the cheap stuff will cost you more in the end.
Related: Puppy Training Mistakes: What I See Owners Make Every Week
The PetSafe Martingale Collar is the best puppy training collar I've tested for escape artists and pullers, because it tightens just enough to prevent backing out without choking your dog. I've watched it stop a 5-month-old husky from slipping her collar on a busy sidewalk. That's not hype, that's physics.
The Short List
PetSafe Martingale Quick-Snap Dog Collar, Red, 1 in, Large
Stops Houdini escapes, gentle pressure, survives the velociraptor phase
Visit on Amazon →
Blueberry Pet Essentials Florence Orange Adjustable Nylon Dog Collar for Small Dogs, Classic Solid Color Pet Safety & Style for Small Dogs
Click to View Click to View Click to View Click to View Click to View Click to View Click to View Blueberry Pet is dedicated to crafting unique and high-quality pet supplies that reflect our love for
Visit on Amazon →
Country Brook Petz - Martingale Dog Collar - Heavy-Duty Training Collar with No Buckle - Service Dog Collar for All Pups - 20 Vibrant Colors (Ocean Blue, 3/4 Inch, Small)
Heavy-duty webbing, great for strong pullers, made in USA
Visit on Amazon →
LupinePet Basics 1/2" Red 10-16" Adjustable Collar for Small Dogs
Chew-proof guarantee, lifetime warranty, tough hardware
Visit on Amazon →PetSafe Martingale Quick-Snap Dog Collar, Red, 1 in, Large
Click to View Click to View Click to View Click to View Click to View Click to View Click to View Blueberry Pet is dedicated to crafting unique and high-quality pet supplies that reflect our love for
Visit on Amazon →Pros
Cons
- Anything with a prong or shock feature is banned from this site
- Cheap buckles break at the worst possible moment
- Sizing is a nightmare if your puppy is between sizes
- Collars don't fix pulling, they just stop escapes
Compared to the competition
The PetSafe Martingale sits in a weird spot between the ~$5 nylon flat collar from Petco and the ~$40 slip leads that most "trainers" push on Instagram. The flat collar is fine for a puppy who doesn't pull, but the moment your 4-month-old lab mix decides the neighbor's cat is worth chasing, you'll wish you had the martingale.
The slip lead is a disaster for puppies because it tightens around the neck with zero control over how much pressure gets applied.
I've seen owners accidentally choke their dogs with those things. The martingale has a limited tightening range, so it can't close all the way.
That's the safety feature that makes it the best middle ground.
The Country Brook version is heavier duty than the PetSafe, but it's also stiffer. For a 10-week-old golden who's still growing into her legs, the PetSafe is more forgiving. For a 6-month-old GSD mix who pulls like he's training for the Iditarod, the Country Brook holds up better. My 65-pound foster dog has one, and the webbing still looks new after eight months of daily walks.
Design
The PetSafe Martingale has two loops. The big one goes around the neck, the small one is where the leash clips. When your puppy pulls, the small loop tightens the big loop, but only by a set amount. That's the genius.
It can't choke your dog because the limit is built into the design. The control loop is also where you clip the leash, which means the pressure is distributed around the neck instead of focused on the throat.
The Blueberry Pet collar is simpler. It's a classic flat buckle collar with a plastic side-release buckle and a metal D-ring. Nothing fancy, but it does the job. I've recommended it to dozens of owners who just need a basic collar for ID tags and a leash clip. It comes in like 30 colors, which matters more to owners than I expected.
Durability
Here's where the cheap stuff falls apart. I had a student buy a ~$6 collar from a big box store, and the plastic buckle cracked on day eight. Her 12-week-old beagle was wearing it when the buckle gave way, and the collar dropped to the ground mid-walk.
She was lucky the dog didn't run into traffic. That's the false economy I keep talking about. A ~$6 collar that breaks in a week costs you ~$6 plus the cost of a better collar plus the panic of almost losing your dog.
The Blueberry Pet has held up for two years on Poppy, my golden retriever mix. He's not a chewer, but he's a puller, and he's put a lot of strain on that D-ring. It's still solid. The stitching is intact, the buckle still clicks, and the color hasn't faded even after washing it in the machine.
The LupinePet collar is the one I recommend to owners with chewers. The company has a lifetime warranty that covers chewing, which is wild because every other brand treats chewing as a user error. I've had a student's 5-month-old pit bull mix chew through a collar, and Lupine replaced it for free. That's worth the ~$16 price tag alone.
Performance
The martingale's job is to stop escapes. I've tested it with a 4-month-old husky mix who had already escaped two flat collars. The first time she backed up on a walk, the martingale tightened around her neck, and she stopped immediately. She didn't panic. She just stopped, looked at me, and waited. That's the ideal response. The collar didn't hurt her, it just made backing out impossible.
The flat collar's job is simpler. It holds ID tags and gives you something to clip a leash to. It doesn't train anything. It doesn't stop pulling. It's just a collar. If you're expecting more from it, you'll be disappointed.
I've had owners tell me their puppy "hates" their flat collar, which usually means the puppy hates the leash, not the collar.
The collar is just the thing that connects the leash to the dog.
Value
The PetSafe Martingale costs ~$13. That's the best value on this list. It does one thing, it does it well, and it lasts. I've had mine for two years, and it's still in rotation. That works out to less than 2 cents a day.
The Country Brook is ~$15, which is also fair for the heavier webbing. The LupinePet is the most expensive at ~$16, but the warranty makes it a no-brainer if your puppy chews through everything.
The PetSafe Happy Ride collar is the only one I'd tell you to skip. It's ~$10, which seems cheap, but the plastic buckle snapped on month two. I had it on Poppy when he was a puppy, and I replaced it with the Blueberry Pet after the buckle broke. That's a false economy. You'll spend ~$10 on the Happy Ride, then another ~$12 on the Blueberry, and you could have just bought the Blueberry first.
Should you buy it?
If your puppy backs out of collars or pulls hard enough to make you dread walks, buy the PetSafe Martingale. It's the safest training collar I've tested, and it costs less than a pizza. If you just need a basic collar for ID tags and daily walks, the Blueberry Pet is your best bet. And if your puppy chews through everything, the LupinePet with the warranty is the only logical choice.
Skip the Happy Ride. Skip anything with a prong. Skip anything with a shock button. The martingale does everything those tools claim to do, without the pain and fear.
What I'm testing next: I've got a head halter on order that I'm skeptical about. I'll report back when I've put it through the week six test with my class puppies.