Most puppy training gear fails for the same boring reason: it was designed for a calm adult dog in a quiet living room, and you own a nine week old who has just discovered the kitchen trash. The leash that worked fine when your puppy sat politely on the rug becomes a wrestling match the first time a leaf blows past. Treats that looked like a bargain get spit onto the sidewalk because they take too long to chew. A clicker with no plan behind it ends up in a drawer next to the unused puzzle toy.
Shopping for puppy training gear is less about finding the fanciest option and more about finding the handful of items that still work in week six, when your puppy has opinions and a longer attention span for squirrels than for you. This guide covers six items that show up in a typical puppy kindergarten kit: a two point no-pull harness with a control leash, a training clicker, two different treat formats, and a crate training book for the human half of the team. Each card below points to the exact product it describes, and no card prints a price, because prices move and your decision should not hinge on a number that changed last Tuesday.
Related: Crate Training a Puppy: The First Two Weeks
Quick answer
The PetSafe Easy Walk 3 in 1 Harness with 2 Point Control Leash, Black, Medium is the strongest fit for puppies who pull on walks and still have soft, developing necks, because it is built around a two point control design rather than pressure on the throat. Choose the Learning Resources Brightkins Training Clicker: Hot Dog instead when your main problem is marking behavior fast enough for a puppy to understand which choice just earned the reward.
Puppy training gear worth comparing
These are the six items this guide covers, ordered with the top pick first.
PetSafe Easy Walk 3 in 1 Harness with 2 Point Control Leash, Black, Medium
A three in one walking harness in black, size medium, sold with a two point control leash. The two point design gives you a front connection and a back connection instead of a single clip at the collar.
Visit on Amazon
Learning Resources Brightkins Training Clicker: Hot Dog
Check current Amazon price
A training clicker from the Learning Resources Brightkins line, shaped like a hot dog. A clicker is a marker: it tells the puppy exactly which moment earned the reward.
Visit on Amazon
(3) PureBites Beef Liver Freeze Dried Dog Treats 4.2oz Bags. Total 12.6oz
Three bags of freeze dried beef liver dog treats, 4.2 ounces each, for 12.6 ounces total. Freeze dried liver is a single ingredient format that breaks into small pieces for repetition.
Visit on Amazon
Happy Howie's Soft Meat Roll Treat, High Protein, Beef, 12 Oz (Pack of 1)
A single 12 ounce soft meat roll treat with high protein beef. The roll format lets you slice or pinch off the exact piece size you want for a session.
Visit on Amazon
Happy Howie's Soft Meat Roll Treat, High Protein, Beef, 12 Oz (Pack of 4)
Four 12 ounce soft meat rolls with high protein beef. The same soft roll format as the single pack, in a larger quantity for households that train daily.
Visit on Amazon
Crate Training for Puppies: How to Crate Train Your Puppy in Just 3 Days: A Step-by-Step Program so Your Pup Will Understand You!
A step by step crate training program for puppies, presented as a three day plan. This is a guide for the owner, not a piece of equipment for the dog.
Visit on AmazonPrices and availability may change. Check the retailer for current details.
How these products were compared
This guide compares treat format and portion control, walk control design and fit, marker tools versus written instruction, pack quantity against how often you train, and how each item matches a puppy's developmental stage. Product names, images, and retailer links are matched by product identifier so that every card points to the product shown.
The comparison is based on what each product is and how it is meant to be used, not on a single afternoon with a single puppy. Format matters more than branding here. A freeze dried liver treat, a soft meat roll, and a clicker are three completely different jobs, and a guide that ranks them against each other on a single scale is not telling you anything useful.
How to choose the right puppy training item
Start with the behavior you are actually trying to change this month, not the behavior you hope to fix by winter.
If the problem is a puppy who drags you down the block, the harness is the relevant purchase. A two point control design gives you a front attachment point, which changes the direction of your puppy's forward motion instead of tightening across the throat, plus a back attachment for everyday walking. That is a meaningful difference for a puppy whose neck and growth plates are still developing. Fit is the part people skip. Measure the girth of your puppy's ribcage behind the front legs, compare that number to the size chart, and recheck the fit every couple of weeks, because a harness that was snug at ten weeks will be tight at sixteen.
If the problem is that your puppy does not seem to know which behavior earned the treat, the answer is a marker, not more treats. A clicker exists to compress the gap between the moment your puppy does the right thing and the moment payment arrives. Pair the click with food a few dozen times before you use it for anything, then keep sessions short. Buy the clicker and read something about how to use it in the same week, because a clicker in a drawer is just a plastic hot dog.
Treat format is the third decision, and it comes down to speed and size. Freeze dried liver breaks into small, dry pieces that do not grease up your fingers, which makes it a good fit for repetition heavy work like name recognition or a first sit. Soft meat rolls are for sessions where you want a slightly larger, more aromatic reward, or where you need to pinch off an exact piece size. Both formats work, and most households end up using one for high distraction work and the other for routine practice. If you want the mechanics of phasing food out, this guide to fading treats without losing the behavior walks through the order of operations.
Pack quantity is a budget question rather than a training question. A single roll and a four pack contain the same product in different amounts. Choose based on how many treats you go through in a week, and remember that a training treat should be pea sized, so a large bag lasts longer than it looks.
Finally, consider whether your bottleneck is the dog or the human. The crate training book is the only item in this group aimed at the owner. If your puppy screams for twenty minutes every time the crate door closes, buying a fourth bag of treats will not fix it, and a structured plan probably will.
PetSafe Easy Walk 3 in 1 Harness with 2 Point Control Leash, Black, Medium
The PetSafe Easy Walk 3 in 1 is a walking harness sold with a matching two point control leash. The three in one label refers to how the harness can be configured, and the two point leash lets you connect at the chest and the back at the same time for maximum steering on a puppy who has not yet learned that a loose leash is the goal.
For a young puppy, the appeal is mechanical rather than magical. A front connection redirects forward pull to the side, which is easier on a developing neck than a flat collar taking the whole load. The back connection gives you a normal walking setup once your puppy settles down. Medium is one size among several, so verify the size chart against your puppy's girth before ordering, and expect to size up at least once during the first year.
The trade off is fit sensitivity. A harness that is too loose will shift and rub, and one that is too tight will restrict shoulder movement, so it is worth taking two minutes to adjust the straps properly the first time and checking them again after a growth spurt. A two point leash also takes a session or two to get used to if you have only ever clipped a leash to a collar. Neither issue is a defect, but both are the kind of thing that makes an owner decide a harness "does not work" when the real problem was a strap that needed to move one notch.
Alternatives to consider
The Learning Resources Brightkins Training Clicker: Hot Dog is better suited to owners who want to sharpen timing and mark behavior precisely, while the (3) PureBites Beef Liver Freeze Dried Dog Treats 4.2oz Bags. Total 12.6oz is a stronger fit when you want a dry, single ingredient reward that breaks into small pieces for rapid repetition.
The Happy Howie's Soft Meat Roll Treat, High Protein, Beef, 12 Oz (Pack of 1) and the Happy Howie's Soft Meat Roll Treat, High Protein, Beef, 12 Oz (Pack of 4) cover the same soft roll format at two quantities, so the choice between them is about how fast your household goes through treats rather than about performance. The Crate Training for Puppies book covers the entirely different problem of teaching a puppy to settle in a crate, and it is the one item here that trains the person holding the leash.
Day-to-day use and maintenance
Treats need a storage plan. Freeze dried liver stays fresher in a sealed container, and a soft meat roll should be wrapped and refrigerated once opened so it does not dry out into something your puppy refuses. Cut or pinch pieces before the session starts, not during it, because fumbling with a roll while your puppy is offering every behavior he knows is how good training sessions fall apart.
The harness is the item that needs the most attention. Rinse or wipe it after muddy walks, check the straps and the stitching periodically, and look under the front legs for any sign of rubbing. Hair loss or redness in the armpit area almost always means the fit is wrong, not that the harness is bad. Walk your puppy on a flat collar only as a backup for the ID tag, not as the primary connection.
The clicker needs no maintenance, but it does need a plan. Charge it with food before you use it, keep it in the same pocket every session so the sound stays consistent, and put it away when you are not actively training so it does not become background noise.
One safety note that applies to every item here: training tools do not replace supervision. A puppy left alone with a harness on, a bag of treats, or a new chewable item is a puppy who can get into trouble. Gear supports a training plan. It does not substitute for one.
Buying checklist
- Measure your puppy's girth behind the front legs and compare it to the harness size chart.
- Choose treat format based on how fast you need to reward, not on which bag looks biggest.
- Confirm that the exact listing includes the two point leash if that is the setup you want.
- Read the cleaning and storage instructions for both the harness and the treats.
- Verify the current retailer price, availability, and return terms before ordering.
Final recommendation
Choose the PetSafe Easy Walk 3 in 1 Harness with 2 Point Control Leash, Black, Medium when leash pulling is the behavior you need to address and your puppy is still growing into his neck and shoulders. Choose the Learning Resources Brightkins Training Clicker: Hot Dog when the gap between your puppy's behavior and your reward is the thing costing you progress. If you are still deciding what to buy first, the honest answer is that the harness changes your daily walks and the clicker changes your timing, and both of those matter more than which bag of treats is on the counter.